Conservative AM Janet Finch Saunders (Aberconwy) takes on Labour First Minister Carwyn Jones on local government funding. In the centre front row – allegedly ignoring Ms Finch Saunders – is the Labour “Local Government Minister” Alun Davies

The Welsh Labour Government’s First Minister Carwyn Jones may have thrown in the towel –  and be about to leave the ring –  but he hasn’t able to resist taking another swipe at the Conservative-run Vale of Glamorgan Council.

In “First Minister’s Questions”, Jones was attempting to parry an attack from the Conservatives about Labour’s grossly unfair formula for the funding for local authorities – an arrangement which advantages Labour councils and disadvantages the Vale.

Conservative AM Janet Finch Saunders takes on “lame duck” First Minister Carwyn Jones to press the case for the Conservative-run Vale of Glamorgan Council to receive fairer funding from the Welsh Labour Government

Carwyn Jones had been asked by Janet Finch Saunders (Conservative AM for Aberconwy) about a review of the local government funding formula [i.e. the way in which the funding of local councils is calculated]  .

She said that a  number of local authorities in Wales were now calling for “equitable, longer-term budgets” – and quoted  the Vale of Glamorgan Council as saying that “there is a well-made case for changes to the formula”.

Labour Local Government Minister Alun Davies first of all ignored Ms Finch Saunders’s plea for more money for the Vale of Glamorgan – and then grinned at her with apparent amusement

Ms Finch Saunders also fired a barb at Alun Davies – the  Welsh Labour Government’s Minister for Local Government – saying he had received a volume of correspondence from local councils – but had taken no notice of it .Looking across the chamber at Alun Davies – lolling in his seat – she said  “He isn’t listening now – he’s actually preferring to completely ignore the question and he is the Cabinet Secretary for Local Government !”

She urged Carwyn Jones – who had already been referred to by the Conservative Leader Andrew R T Davies as a “lame duck“- to speak to the aforesaid Local Government Minister on behalf of local councils in Wales “to ensure there is a more sustainable  funding model and formula going forward. It’s the very least our local authorities  deserve”

“Lame duck” First Minister Carwyn Jones parried Ms Finch Saunders by claiming the Vale allocated less cash per head to school pupils than any other authority in Wales – failing to mention that this situation has been brought about by the Welsh Labour Government’s unfair funding formula

This gutsy display from Ms Finch Saunders  brought forth from Carwyn Jones a predictable, question-dodging attack. He said “I think the Vale of Glamorgan need to explain why  they spend less on education than anywhere else in Wales – per head. That is under her party – and that is something that they will have to explain to their electorate”.

Carwyn Jones claimed “We fund local authorities at a far higher level than would be the case if they were in England. We look to protect them as far as we can but it is inevitable that there will be difficulties and a squeeze on local authorities because we ourselves are being squeezed”

[ PDN Note: In fact the Vale of Glamorgan’s financial problems stem entirely from the fact that it receives the lowest allocation of funding from the Welsh Labour Government of any local authority in Wales bar one, and ranks No 21 out of the 22 local authorities in Wales in terms of cash received from the Welsh Government. It means taxpayers in the Vale of Glamorgan are subsidising most of the other councils in Wales]







About NewsNet

Penarth Daily News email address newsnet@sky.com. Penarth Daily News is an independent free on-line fair and balanced news service published by NewsNet Ltd covering the town of Penarth in the Vale of Glamorgan, Wales, UK. All our news items are based on the information we receive or discover at the time of publication and are published on the basis that they are accurate to the best of our knowledge and belief at that time. Comments posted on the site by commentators reflect their opinions and are not necessarily shared, endorsed or supported by Penarth Daily News.
This entry was posted in Penarth Daily News. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Yet another example of how Welsh Labour look after their own. Even when challenged on the facts they have the bare faced cheek to blame someone else. Imagine if the shoe was on the other foot, the noise of complaints would be deafening. The sooner they’re out of power at the WAG the better.

  2. The Tax payer says:

    That’s the pot calling the kettle Black I think. He really should go now and don’t know how he sleeps at night after what happened to Carl Sargeant. Hope he gets what’s coming and due to him

  3. Drew says:


Comments are closed.